| 1 | EN 14509 Product Compliance | 25% | The offered panel configuration is covered by valid EN 14509 conformity documentation. | Declaration of Performance, CE-related documentation where applicable, product specification, and identification of the assessed panel system. | Full points when documentation matches the exact core, facings, joint design, thickness range, and intended use. |
| 2 | Factory Production Control | 15% | Documented production-control procedures are implemented and maintained for the panel product. | Factory production-control manual, inspection plans, batch records, calibration records, nonconformity procedures, and audit reports. | Reduce points for incomplete records, uncontrolled subcontracting, or evidence that cannot be linked to the supplied product. |
| 3 | Independent Performance Testing | 15% | Declared performance values are supported by testing or assessment methods appropriate to EN 14509. | Reports covering thermal performance, mechanical properties, dimensional characteristics, durability, and relevant fire performance. | Full points for current, traceable reports from competent laboratories with matching product construction. |
| 4 | ISO 9001 Quality Management System | 15% | A current ISO 9001 certificate covers the manufacturing site and the relevant design, production, or sales activities. | Certificate number, validity dates, certification scope, issuing certification body, and accreditation details where available. | Do not award full points for an expired certificate or a scope that excludes panel manufacturing. |
| 5 | Thermal Performance | 10% | Declared thermal transmittance values are clearly stated for the exact panel thickness and construction. | Declared or designed U-value, thermal conductivity data, thickness tolerance, joint details, and calculation assumptions. | Compare like-for-like thicknesses and account for joints, fasteners, temperature conditions, and declared tolerances. |
| 6 | Mechanical and Structural Performance | 8% | Load-bearing, deflection, fastener, and span information is available for the proposed panel system. | Structural design tables, test reports, steel-facings data, core density information, span limits, and installation assumptions. | Give higher scores to transparent tables supported by testing or engineering assessment rather than generic claims. |
| 7 | Fire Performance Documentation | 5% | The fire classification or reaction-to-fire information is stated for the exact core, facing, adhesive, and joint configuration. | Classification reports, test reports, declared reaction-to-fire performance, and limitations on use. | Do not transfer a fire rating from a different core, facing thickness, coating, or joint system. |
| 8 | Dimensional and Surface Quality | 4% | The manufacturer controls panel length, width, thickness, squareness, joint fit, coating, and surface appearance. | Inspection standards, allowable tolerances, sample approval procedure, coating specifications, and final inspection records. | Higher scores require measurable acceptance criteria and documented corrective-action records. |
| 9 | Traceability and Technical Support | 3% | Every production batch can be traced to raw materials, manufacturing records, inspection results, and shipping documents. | Batch labels, material certificates, packing lists, technical data sheets, installation manuals, and complaint-handling procedures. | Full points when technical support remains available through design, installation, and after-sales stages. |